I live at the beach and I want to avoid wet sandy feet in my 1993 Accord LX. I have had excellent wear and durability from a 4 pc dark grey set from Rubbermaid. They fit like a glove and dont move around on the carpeted floors, plus the surface is grooved to trap dirt and sand. Take them out and hose them off every week, and they still look great. I got them at Pep Boys for $16.99.

 

I just picked up a set of rubber floor mats from Sam's Club (Walmart's Box Store) for about 20$. They have some preset trimmable area's. They work out pretty well and don't move. There are multiple colors available. They work for me.